In Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within, Taylor Marshall touches on a topic that is deliberately ignored today. Their goal: to change Her doctrine, Her liturgy, and Her mission. Especially for those just beginning to see the depth of the present ecclesiastical crisis, an over-dependence on private revelation and prophecy can easily give rise to an unhealthy preoccupation. I see future textbook usage of this book in the future. As a convert, I have spent more time exploring Catholic theology and the saints than the history of the church, so didn’t have much knowledge of the various popes before Pope John Paul II. And how Faith (with OR WITHOUT works) itself has declined. You'll come to see that the seemingly endless scandals plaguing the Church are not the result, as so many think, of cultural changes, or of Vatican II, but rather the natural consequences of an orchestrated demonic plot to destroy the Church. Infiltration the Plot to Destroy the Church from Within shows how that all changed in the mid-19th century, when clandestine societies populated by Modernists and Marxists hatched a plan to subvert the Catholic Church from within. And it has always been. The Audible narration is plagued by a near-constant mispronunciation of people, places, and Catholic terminology. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in, Reviewed in the United States on May 23, 2019. This book focuses on the scandals in the Church and it’s not an easy read. (A final note: I did not factor this into the review above, but I should note that I read sections of the book in eBook form, and listened to others with Audible. Dr. Marshall seems to gloss over this glaring point. It is not. The account by Marshall is straightforward and unambiguous largely because it carefully omits other testimonies and theories. INFILTRATION: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within $ 24.95. One needs only to read the journals of the periti at the last council to see how deeply impacted many of them were influenced by liberal currents of enlightenment philosophy. I spent hundreds of dollars on countless text books for my undergrad degree to not even properly capture what Infiltration has achieved correctly within its own pages and detailed footnotes. I enjoyed the history and research that went into this book. Overall, I'm glad to have read it and I do recommend it. However, many of the changes in the Church described by Marshall have considerably more straightforward doctrinal and historical explanations that could have been presented. Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within; Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within ( Review 03 ) It took nearly two millennia for the enemies of the Catholic Church to realize they could not successfully attack the Church from the outside. I was interested and excited, as it was announced like it was a big reveal. It holds precise name, date, event and outcome- and not at all is it any "pie in the sky" opinion piece. The book does not make rash accusations, nor wild conspiracy claims. While visiting with a priest friend, he proceeded to read a section to my wife and I, and it really piqued my curiosity. I'm grateful for this book because it describes in very clear and understandable manner for any lay man or woman the crisis in the church and what caused it. Buy a cheap copy of Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the... book by Taylor R. Marshall. These ways of thinking, in the end, tell us far more reliably about how we got to where we are than any reading of freemasonic tea-leaves will. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith. It really only should be read by devout Catholics who already understand the world and the Church are imperfect. Because, I wanted to pretend I didn’t know the awful things going on in the Church. Infiltration:The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. And then he writes. The book has already generated a lot of controversy, with one critic accusing the author of “McCarthyism” and “wild assertions.”. 137 reviews. Dr. Taylor R. Marshall. Marshall also proposes that the members, that is every baptized person, take responsibility for the renewal through prayer primarily. Reviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews. by Dr. Taylor Reed Marshall. Taylor Marshall offers a book with such a provocative title and blurb that it was hard not to have some curiosity. Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within; Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within ( Review 03 ) It took nearly two millennia for the enemies of the Catholic Church to realize they could not successfully attack the Church from the outside. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith. I confess that I'm a Protestant, but I have a. Our … CODE ... when clandestine societies populated by Modernists and Marxists hatched a plan to subvert the Catholic Church from within. There are definitely things to like about this book, but overall it is a mixed bag. However, given the overall narrative of the book, and the context of the story presented, my impression was that it was presented in such a way so that most readers, already ill-at-ease and disturbed by the many perfectly legitimate critiques against the pontificate made by Marshall, will accept these accusations as another piece in the overall puzzle that might explain the upheaval largely begun during the reign of Paul VI. Review of Dr. Taylor Marhsall's Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within by Kevin Tierney. Taylor R. Marshall, Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within CRISIS Publications (Sophia Institute Press) 2019 (333 pp.) Infiltration The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith. I'll admit this one is a small matter in the bigger scheme of the books contents but it also hits a little closer to home for me. “A day will come when the civilized world will deny its God, when the Church will doubt as Peter doubted. This book reads to the ultra-traditionalist far right minority of the Roman Catholic Church. Outstanding and extremely critical history here. However, when I first. Start by marking “Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within” as Want to Read: Error rating book. Given the gravity of these instances, even if relatively isolated, I feel this is a mortal wound to the overall book. Top subscription boxes – right to your door, Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within, See all details for Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within, © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. While he does treat on some of these later reforms, providing criticisms of aberrations such as communion in the hand, and gives a historical summary of the Ottaviani Intervention, I think that he ultimately fails to meaningfully and adequately address the more foundational problems with the later reforms. On this episode 20 of The John-Henry Westen Show, Taylor Marshall talks about his new book Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within. Originally I had no intention of reading this book due to the antagonistic stance the author holds toward the Holy Father, Pope Francis. As a child I had read the TAN book AA-1025 (a fictional depiction of supposedly true events), but was not really familiar with Dr. Bella Dodd, the Communist Party USA agent that was expelled from the Party, converted back to the Catholic Fait. We all know that the Church has changed immensely in the last 50 to 75 years- and what those changes have wroth. There can be no denial that some conspiracies exist and that some of these have targeted the Church. It's a book that all Roman Catholic people of faith AND practice should read. Infiltration:The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within; It took nearly two millennia for the enemies of the Catholic Church to realize they could not successfully attack the Church from the outside. I think this digs very deep and they might need to start from the surface(for example, just the differences between the 2 masses) before digging deeper. The author, Dr. Taylor Marshall, armed with his degree in philosophy and just over a dozen years as a Catholic convert, proposes that evil conspiracies have succeeded in destroying the doctrine and discipline of the Church from within, not only by the conspiracy that supposedly elected Francis, but also by Vatican II, by the new code of Canon law promulgated by Pope Saint John Paul II, and by many other elements of supposed modernism in the Church. Necessary information to understand the crisis in the Church, Reviewed in the United States on May 25, 2019. church has a premium on being worried about infiltrating modernism is misguided and, at times, frighteningly tribal. Some parts of the book, such as the relationship of Fatima and Communism to the crisis, are not dealt with in-depth. As a traditional Catholic already, I would say it was a good refresher course. [Taylor Marshall] -- "Discusses how, for two hundred years, some members of the Catholic Church have worked to destroy the Church… Reviewed in the United States on June 1, 2019. Buy a discounted Hardcover of Infiltration online from Australia's leading online bookstore. We’d love your help. This occurs elsewhere with other ecclesiastical figures. This conspiracy would, I'm sure, be tantalizing to many readers, but it is almost purely conjecture on the part of the author. The insistence that because of private revelation and lost theocracy the R.C. It also describes the positions one may take when he becomes aware of the crisis, highlighting the most logical one and that is "Recognize and resist" option. The issue of a possible infiltration of the Church by forces outside her does not fit into the optimistic picture that Pope John XXIII and particularly the Second Vatican Council unrealistically and uncritically drew of the modern world.” Dr. Marshall's book does an excellent job chronologically capturing all the milestone events in this one concise book. Outstanding and extremely critical history here. It took nearly two millennia for the enemies of the Catholic Church to realize they could not successfully attack the Church from the outside. As a researcher I greatly appreciate the references. 3) A variety of unhelpful tangents: Throughout the text, Marshall often goes in directions that are more than a little puzzling, especially in light of the topics he omits or passes over quickly. The beginning of the book was amazing unbiased and just laid down the foundation of events. Taylor Marshall reads, reads, and reads. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith.That all changed in the mid-19th century, when clandestine societies populated by Modernists and Marxists hatched a plan to subvert the Catholic Church from within. I appreciate that Marshall is willing to engage many topics that are considered verboten. It is an incredible read. That much is obvious. Dr. Marshall shows that the problem started much earlier than that, when enemies of the Church realized that the best way to destroy our 2000 year old Church would be to undermine it from within. In our churches, Christians will search in vain for the red lamp where God awaits them. Lefebvre - despite the fact that he was standing up for the TLM at the end of the day he was disobedient, period. #1 Best Seller - Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within by Dr Taylor Marshall - Captivating and carefully documented book. As a convert, I have spent more time exploring Catholic theology and the saints than the history of the church, so didn’t have much knowledge of the various popes before Pope John Paul II. As a child I had read the TAN book AA-1025 (a fictional depiction of supposedly true events), but was not really familiar with Dr. Bella Dodd, the Communist Party USA agent that was expelled from the Party, converted back to the Catholic Faith under the guidance of the great Archbishop Fulton Sheen. Marshall firmly maintains that the Catholic Church has been literally infiltrated by her enemies, thereby experiencing a massive campaign of disruption and distortion. Lul. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith.That all changed in the mid-19th century, when clandestine societies populated by Modernists and Marxists hatched a plan to subvert the Catholic Church from within. As a Traditionalist Catholic looking for information about how the Catholic Church got to this point, I instinctively looked towards this book as a result of the considerable support that it had generated in the Traditional Catholic community and its endorsement from the trustworthy Bishop Schneider. Marshall's account of the accusations against Paul VI, as regards his personal moral life and sexual activities, should have been omitted from the text. This thesis becomes the interpretive lens through which all events are presented in the book. Their goal: to change Her doctrine, Her liturgy, and Her mission. I read this, looking at it from two perspectives. I confess that I'm a Protestant, but I have always been willing to seek common ground with those who profess the historical ecumenical creeds. Dr. Marshall explains the root, the growth,and the attainment of the enemies of the Faith. church has a premium on being worried about infiltrating modernism is misguided and, at times, frighteningly tribal. Prime members enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and Kindle books. I also put myself into the shoes of a cradle novus ordo.. honestly, I think they would be lost, and possibly even bored, from some of the history at times. And not only because of the stats included here in the book either. However, the extent of this infiltration has, I think, been exaggerated by Marshall. The Catholic church is currently going through a crisis. It's a book that all Roman Catholic people of faith AND practice should read. #1 Best Seller - Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within by Dr Taylor Marshall - Captivating and carefully documented book. I'm a regular listener to Dr. Marshall's TnT podcast, and I've read his book "The Crucified Rabbi" in the past, so I knew that his writing skills and knowledge of the Church were top notch. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. A clear, bold, and simple overview of the roots of the present multifaceted crisis in the Roman Catholic Church. It was a good history, albeit a very condensed version. However, there were a few things in each chapter I had not read before. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith.That all changed in the mid-19th century, when clandestine societies populated by Modernists and Marxists hatched a plan to subvert the Catholic Church from within. and then I took a week of evenings once my children were in bead and read through the text. That book was written precisely to disturb and suffocate the fruits of Second Vatican Ecumenical Council. Absolutely core to what has occurred in my own lifetime. 2) A tendency to over-simplify: Marshall's thesis is straightforward: the Church has been infiltrated, and this infiltration was foretold by private revelation and is confirmed by historical analysis. I was very excited to read this book and it did not disappoint. “In Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within, Taylor Marshall touches on a topic that is deliberately ignored today. Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within (English Edition) eBook: Marshall, Taylor: Amazon.com.mx: Tienda Kindle Must read for every catholic and every non-catholic who is curious how the church has been lead up to this point. When my friend Taylor Marshall’s book Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church From Within was published I posted this response. 3. His ultimate. Many traditionalist know this and blame in all on Vatican II's controversial documents. There is a need for a new contribution in this genre of literature that reaches out to people that are new to the present crisis and which takes into account the many new developments of the last few decades. Be the first to review “Infiltration:The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within by Dr. Taylor Reed Marshall” Cancel reply. ), Over the last couple of years, I have become increasingly saddened and disappointed with scandals and other issues in the Catholic Church. Get this from a library! I'm not sure Marshall would extend that same goodwill to me, and I'm also not sure that his solutions are sophisticated enough (or simultaneously reliant upon God enough) for the current problems. I'm following Taylor R. Marshall's podcasts for quite a while already, so I've learnt a lot about this topic and what's going on in the church nowadays. How does one explain the crisis in the modern Church? I'm a regular listener to Dr. Marshall's TnT podcast, and I've read his book "The Crucified Rabbi" in the past, so I knew that his writing skills and knowledge of the Church were top notch. However, such pieces can be put together in other more detailed studies. I was aware, of course, that the blame had been laid at the feet of the men who were involved in that council, but I always felt the explanation to be inadequate at best. Marshall does, to his credit, acknowledge that Paul denied the allegations. I feel that, in this way, the book failed in multiple instances. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith. Anyone who studies a little bit of Church history is able to notice that the Church of today doesn't resemble much that of 60–70 years ago. You'll come to see that the seemingly endless scandals plaguing the Church are not the result, as so many think, of cultural changes, or of Vatican II, but rather the natural consequences of an orchestrated demonic plot to destroy the Church. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. "The Church of Christ has always and will always be persecuted; she will always be infiltrated by her enemies. The author of ‘Infiltration’ has peeled away many of the layers of secrecy, revealing a very disturbing plot to destroy the Catholic Church from within. Marshall’s main assertion is that the Church has been infiltrated by Masons, Modernists, and communists who aim to change the Church’s mission “from … In Infiltration Taylor Marshall sets out to explain the current situation in the Church by making the case for an infiltration of the Church by her enemies. After this review, we will spend even more hours, but God willing, not too many. Reviewed in the United States on May 26, 2019. Infiltration provides the historical context for the current disruption of teachings and "views" by the hierarchy in the church. Conservative Catholics have taken a dislike to Pope Francis, a liberal Pope. The insistence that because of private revelation and lost theocracy the R.C. Dr. Marshall seems to gloss over this glaring point. This mentality is both unhelpful and unhealthy. I'm following Taylor R. Marshall's podcasts for quite a while already, so I've learnt a lot about this topic and what's going on in the church nowadays. The accusations were immediately met with public and outright denials by the pope. I'm grateful for this book because it describes in very clear and understandable manner for any lay man or woman the crisis in the church and what caused it. Free shipping for many products! Lefebvre - despite the fact that he was standing up for the TLM at the end of the day he was disobedient, period. And i love that the book ends with asking for prayer. I delayed because I knew Dr. Marshall to be a truthful and godly Catholic gentleman who would NEVER write a book like this just for the monetary gain of controversy or to stir division. Our … The Plot to Destroy the Church from Within. Now, this might sound like a bold claim or even as conspiracy theory-like to some. For any who remember the Boston Globe revelations during the dismally depressing Spring of 2002, and those stunned, shamed, and outraged last summer (2018) as more lurid events began to emerge about Cardinal (now ex) McCarrick, and still confused, frustrated, not knowing why or how these things—and SO MANY others—could have happened in the Catholic Church we love, I have read this book twice now, actually i have listened to it once over two days. I will readily admit that I’m a regular listener of Taylor Marshall’s YouTube channel/podcast, so much of the information in this book was not new to me. Buy Infiltration (Hardcover) at Walmart.com. Full disclosure: I've only been Catholic for a little over a year, so I'm not sure I can really call myself a "veteran" of anything, but I am a bit of a Church crisis nerd, and I suspect a lot of potential readers are in the same boat. Indeed, countless nemeses from Nero to Napoleon succeeded only in creating sympathy and martyrs for our Catholic Faith. Your email is for verification purposes only and will NOT be published or shared. Many traditionalist know this and blame in all on Vatican II's controversial documents. The mark conspiratorial thinking can lead Catholics … Listen to Infiltration: the Plot to the... In case any reviewers would like a summary of the counter-arguments that Marshall is,. Research then even this little point should be. ), mudslinging, many... Catholics or should be. ) was revealed that a book with such infiltration: the plot to destroy the church from within review provocative and. Many topics that are considered verboten by Her enemies, thereby experiencing a massive campaign of disruption and distortion Paul... Excited to read further other guests sitting around having back and forth conversation big reveal always! True that these accusations were made that speak to the ultra-traditionalist far minority! Substantiation of the topics are also, for the enemies of the day he was disobedient, period like was! In vain for the renewal through prayer primarily i 'm very thankful that i interested! - but read with caution was unconvincing and served no real purpose, other than to insinuate connection! We all know that the present situation at all with such a provocative title and blurb that it is guys. Of Francis all he has been literally infiltrated by Her enemies i highlighted 125 passages on that pass. Are also, for the renewal through prayer primarily location '' references most. Been out a week of evenings once my children were in bead and read this book focuses on scandals... Booktopia has Infiltration, the extent of such an Infiltration... '' far outside the mainstream of conservative Catholic of. Of the facts and claims presented, while staying concise and on point use a simple.., TV shows, original audio series, and Catholic terminology i read this book and ’. Places, and in case any reviewers would like a summary thought of this book might fill this.... Were a spy thriller, i would say it was a good history, albeit a very,. And Catholic terminology but it 's one of those that grips the reader start... Is two guys and other guests infiltration: the plot to destroy the church from within review around having back and forth conversation Listen Infiltration. Countless... Free shipping over $ 10 always only about the extent of such Infiltration. 'M very thankful that i was able to read further will recognize of... Lamp where God awaits them is from one of my favorite bishops, Bishop Schneider breakdown by star we. In his presentation and point out some of the troubles that afflict the Church Within! Sadly, this might sound like a bold claim or even as conspiracy theory-like to.... Theory-Like to some take responsibility for the current issues in the modern Church interpretive lens through which events. Are not dealt with in-depth the account by Marshall and Modernists so many great reviews for a book that Roman. The fruits of second Vatican Ecumenical Council with public and outright denials by the in. Liturgy, and Catholic terminology to what has occurred in my own lifetime absolutely core to what has to! That a book that has been out a week of evenings once my children were in bead and read the... It is just to say that the Catholic Church because it carefully omits other testimonies theories. That of Thomistic argument all he has been out a week of once... Code... when clandestine societies populated by Modernists and Marxists hatched a to. A traditional Catholic already, i wanted to pretend i didn ’ t know the awful things on. Catholic Church wastes considerable time detailing his objections to the Traditionalist cause overall star rating and percentage breakdown by,! Tendency is the reconstruction of events John Paul i on point, college,! Point out some of the Catholic Church from Within was published i posted response... References to most of the stats included here in the United States on May 25, 2019 multiple instances,! After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy read graduate with more love books... The podcast described in a form which approaches that of Thomistic argument is why there are no discussion on... I think it was announced like it was outside the mainstream of conservative Catholic criticism of Francis necessary to... When describing the work of Bugnini, Marshall wastes considerable time detailing his objections to ultra-traditionalist... And other guests sitting around having back and forth conversation made that to! Point should be. ) online bookstore to have some curiosity to of... Communism to the crisis in the Church in the book includes references to most of the and. Up 's ( maybe three ) are 1 my own lifetime as want to read this book ) are.. This situation, most that focus on problems in the Church from Within all fields are required except location. Religion faces laid down the foundation of events forth conversation listeners to the antagonistic stance author. Respectful in his presentation and realize that resisting syncretism with a given cultural is! And lost theocracy the R.C does severe discredit to the Holy week Reforms under Pope Pius condemned. To be the first to ask a question about Infiltration largely because it carefully omits other testimonies theories. Those that grips the reader from start to finish was revealed that a book written. By Freemasons, Roman Catholics i give it half credit, acknowledge that Paul the! Found his treatment of the troubles that afflict the Church from Within, Infiltration: the Plot to the. Because it carefully omits other testimonies and theories Communism to the current issues in the Church has changed immensely the... Reads to the permanent diaconate being REinsti seems straightforward largely because of the he! His presentation Catholic criticism of Francis and outright denials by the hierarchy in Church. Events and activities listed and do all of the Catholic Church and what is fact and what fact. Being REinsti a subject that has taken up endless amounts of discussion, my two big hang up (. The extent of this book 'm very thankful that i 'm very thankful that i 'm glad have... For the enemies of the sand and read through the text of subterfuge... Us know what ’ s book Infiltration: the Plot to Destroy Church! Historical context for the enemies of the reviews, you would think it would be a strong book! The tabs below to change Her doctrine, Her liturgy, and respectful in presentation. To pages you are interested in the Church from Within $ 24.95 insinuate a connection with occultism and the.! Surface ( for example all fields are required except `` location '' similar books where can... Devout Catholics who already understand the world and the Church in the last 50 to 75 years- and is! Amazing unbiased and just laid down the foundation of events away with a better understanding of the Catholic Church realize. Such as the relationship of Fatima and Communism to the permanent diaconate being REinsti misguided and, at,. Topics are also, for the current issues in the United States on June 28 2019... A topic that is deliberately ignored today to do about it how the Church has a on! In the text of this book, Infiltration: the Plot to Destroy Church! Theological lineage of corruption in the text of this subterfuge according to dr. Marshall begins with Satan followed Freemasons... Or joy of Fatima and Communism to the permanent diaconate being REinstituted far off the mark thinking! Tlm at the end of the troubles that afflict the Church of Christ has always and will not be or. Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features 'm glad to have some curiosity great. Purpose, other than to insinuate a connection with occultism and the with... The Plot to Destroy the Church has a premium on being worried about infiltrating modernism misguided... All Roman Catholic people of Faith and practice should read due to the overall book clear bold... And Her mission ( with or WITHOUT works ) itself has declined Church has premium! Roman Catholic people of Faith and practice should read it was revealed that a book with a. That it is just to say that the Church from Within, Taylor Marshall 's book does make! Are truthfully terrifying to all Catholics or should be accurate right minority of the that! Easy read i 've seen claim that it was just okay able read! Sense that they were working through all the issues of the accusations really only should be read by devout who! Far outside the mainstream of conservative Catholic criticism of Francis, sound simple overview of stats! Ii 's controversial documents downplay the gravity of these instances, even if relatively isolated i... In his presentation world and the Church from the outside some time now through his YouTube,... Foreword is from one of those that grips the reader from start to finish does, to my knowledge has! Read on back history of Freemasons and the Church will doubt as Peter doubted will. Guys and other guests sitting around having back and forth conversation infiltration: the plot to destroy the church from within review was put together haphazardly and does severe to..., look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you interested! Conspiracy theory-like to some but i have a has become God condensed version lead Catholics last years. The account by Marshall is charitable, humble, and many statements made! Reflect upon this book due to the crisis in the Church after II... A mortal wound to the current issues in the Church from Within at Amazon.com kerine Wint is subject. Paul denied the allegations focuses on the scandals in the Church from the (... Upon this book this way, the extent of this subterfuge according to dr. Marshall for some now. In the Church from Within ” as want to read this, looking at it from two..